Downsizing the Sleigh

I love singing live for an audience with an orchestra – there’s really nothing like it. But all orchestras – especially community orchestras – aren’t created equal. Beyond differences in experience, there also can be differences in instrumentation, which can create some interesting challenges when adapting a piece like “Mrs. Santa Claus” from the studio to the stage.

The Challenge of Missing Voices

When I’m in the studio, I have the great luxury of writing for whatever combination of instruments I want to use. Full symphonic orchestra? No problem. Ukulele, Pedal Steel Guitar, Choir, and String Bass? Why not.

But community orchestras may not always be able to cover all of the parts in the original arrangement. Sometimes this happens because the original includes unusual instruments, but sometimes it’s just because the group is smaller. Either way, adjustments may be necessary. If key counter-melodies or harmonies are assigned to instruments that aren’t being played, the arrangement can end up a little thin.

Rethinking the Orchestration

This happened most recently in preparations for my concert December 12, where I’ll be singing Mrs. Santa Claus with the Brockport Symphony Orchestra. I originally wrote this arrangement with the Brockport group in mind, but the orchestra’s personnel has changed slightly since then. That meant some parts of the arrangement had to be revised for this concert.

The goal wasn’t to reinvent the wheel, but to intelligently modify the orchestration to fit the instruments available for the concert. It’s actually a fun exercise in musical economy. Sometimes, a more intimate, tightly knit arrangement can bring out a completely different kind of charm.

If you are in the Rochester area, I would love to see you at this concert on December 12. In the meantime, you can stream the original version of “Mrs. Santa Claus” online. Listen for the differences, and then let me know which version you prefer! 🎶

Scroll to Top